No recession in Indian economy: FM Nirmala Sitharaman
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Wednesday launched a spirited defence of her handling of the economy, comparing macroeconomic indicators with past Congress rules and said the growth may have slowed down but the economy will never slip into recession.
Replying to a short-duration discussion on the state of the economy in the Rajya Sabha, she said steps taken by the government post her maiden Budget have started bearing fruits and some sectors such as automobiles have shown signs of recovery.
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman
Allaying concerns over revenue position of the government, she said direct tax and GST collections have both seen an increase in the first seven months of the current fiscal when compared to the same period of the last year.
The Congress, the TMC and the Left parties, however, staged a walkout of the House saying she was reading out her budget speech rather than addressing issues facing the economy.
"Every step being taken is in the interest of the country... looking at the economy with discerning view, you see that the growth may have come down, but it's not a recession yet or it won't be recession ever," she said.
She then went on to compare GDP growth during the Narendra Modi-led BJP government since 2014 and that witnessed in the previous five years under the UPA-II regime, saying inflation was below the targeted range, economic expansion was much better and so were other macroeconomic indicators.
India's growth outlook has weakened sharply this year, with a crunch that started with non-banking finance institutions spreading to retail businesses, carmakers, home sales, and heavy industries.
The Indian economy expanded by five percent in April-June, its slowest annual pace since 2013 and the projections are that it may have slowed down further in the second quarter, making six consecutive quarters of slowing growth, a first since 2012.
This is despite a recent series of fiscal stimulus, including a reduction in corporate tax rates.
Sitharaman blamed the fall in GDP growth in the last two financial years to the lagged effect of twin balance sheet crisis of stress on banks due to non-performing assets (NPAs) or bad loans on the one hand and heavily indebted corporates on the other, resulting from the UPA regime lending.
Rejecting criticism that her maiden Budget on July 5 had failed to address concerns of a slowing economy and so had to resort to announcing measures within a month of the passing of the Budget by Parliament, she said the Economic Survey and she had recognised the need for recapitalisation of bank and reforms in her Budget speech.
Capital infusion of Rs 70,000 crore in banks, flowing from that speech, had led to rise in the ability of banks to lend and over Rs 2.5 lakh crore has been given in loans during the recent outreach programme, she said.
The Finance Minister did not see a problem of liquidity that forced the slowing of the economy but that of the flow of funds.
Reforms such as Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code are yielding results.
On the Goods and Services Tax (GST), she said out of the Rs 6.63 lakh crore net collections targeted in the year through March 31, 2020, Rs 3.26 lakh crore had been collected during April to October. Month-wise GST collections have grown year-on-year, she said, adding direct tax collections at Rs 6.86 lakh crore in April-October too had seen a growth of 4.8 percent.
"GST is not doing badly. It could do better," she said.
She reeled out numbers to defend the economic track record and said the direct tax-to-GDP ratio has risen from 5.5 percent in 2014-15 to 5.98 percent in 2018-19.
Also, revenue receipts have grown by 18 percent, revenue expenditure by 13.97 percent and capital expenditure by 15.31 percent in the first half of this year.
Is "everything is coming down, not at all," she said. "We are conscious of the challenges faced by sectors... we shall ensure every sector and challenges are heard by us."
She said Prime Minister Modi himself was taking personal interest "so that economy can be on a higher trajectory."
As many as 32 steps have been announced post-July 5 Budget to revive growth and are bearing fruits, the minister said.
FDI inflows in 2009-14 were USD 189.5 billion and the same were $283.9 billion under BJP rule in the following five years, she said.
Sitharaman further said the government was coming out with lots of reforms and "taking decisions so that the economy can get better moving on higher growth trajectory"
She also took a jibe on the opposition party members who accused her government of "regressive taxation" policies.
"...whoever brought in the MAT, I know it was brought in 1987 but 10 long years (UPA I and II) it was only aggravated rather than withdrawn, MAT which is seen even today a very very regressive tax," she said. She also referred to the 2012 retrospective taxation decision taken by the then government.
The minister said that it "surprises" her that the NDA government was being condemned for reducing corporate tax by those whose government in 1991 globalised Indian economy.
"Who are the ones who did globalisation. Who opened the economy. Why it was done. It was okay then. Now it is not correct. What is this hypocrisy," she said.
Earlier during the discussion, opposition parties attacked the government over the economy saying the country was heading towards a deep crisis and people do not have money to even buy day-to-day articles.
(Edited by Saheli Sen Gupta)