Why we don't talk about Chhattisgarh's fluorosis problem

Friday July 07, 2017 , 4 min Read

Twenty years ago, Chhattisgarh’s Amatikra village wasn't full of men and women with bent backs and severe dental issues.

Ved Prasad (45), a farmer in Amatikra village in Korba district, Chhattisgarh, didn't always have a bent back. Twenty years ago, he walked in an upright manner but over the last five years, he's had severe back pain which has affected his gait. Bhola Singh (50) from the same village has an identical story to tell. Both these farmers visited local government hospitals to find ways to ease their pain but came back time and again without any real solution. Frustration and pain finally got to them but they had to trudge 80 km from Amatikra to the Jan Swasthya Sahyog (JSS) hospital to find an answer.

They were suffering from fluorosis.

Amatikra residents with skeletal fluorosis.

What is fluorosis?

Fluorosis is a disease caused by the excessive intake of fluoride. Higher concentrations of fluoride in drinking water results in an increasing risk of fluoride-prone diseases such as dental and skeletal fluorosis, which affect the teeth and bones. Fluoride is present in some rocks and is soluble in water. When the fluoride in rocks comes in contact with groundwater, the groundwater becomes unfit for human consumption. Fluoride can't be seen with the naked eye. Only lab tests can detect its presence.

What is the permissible fluoride limit?

Ved Prasad was the first person from Amatikra who requested the JSS team to have a look at his village's health problems. He is suffering from Skeletal Fluorosis.

Moderate amounts of fluoride ingestion will cause dental damage, but long-term ingestion of more than the permissible range of fluoride could lead to potentially severe skeletal problems. As per WHO and ISO 10500 (1991) standards, only 1.5 mg/L and 1.0 mg/L of fluoride respectively are safe for human consumption. A study conducted by JSS in May 2012 revealed some shocking data about the water quality at Amatikra.

Fluoride contamination at Amatikra

Most of the 41 water sources at present, which included 25 hand pumps, 14 wells, a tube well and a pond, had high concentrations of fluoride. 18 of the 25 hand pumps contained more than 1 ppm while the remaining 7 contained more than 5 ppm. The tube well and the pond both had 6 ppm and 12 ppm of fluoride respectively. When asked whether this was always the case, the villagers vehemently disagreed and said that 20 years ago, there wasn't as much of an incidence of back ache or pain in the hands and legs. So, what has changed?

Their drinking water source

Earlier on, the village had only three dug wells and also used water from the Teti river which was 1.5 km away. In the early 1990s, the state government, in order to provide drinking water to the villagers, dug several borewells, dug wells and also installed 25 hand pumps without checking the groundwater quality or doing any further hydro-geological studies. Yet another government initiative in the name of so-called development has resulted in what we see today.

Rajman bai and Mankuver bai, residents of Amatikra, are suffering from Skeletal Fluorosis. Most of the women above the age of 45 have been diagnosed with this disease.

“The condition of the fluorosis patients of Amatikra village is terrible. Most of the villagers are now suffering from dental and skeletal fluorosis”, says Yogesh Jain, a senior doctor at JSS. The villagers look frail and most of them are unable to stand upright or walk without bending forward. "The farmers of this village are not able to participate in their agricultural activities properly due to weakness", says 53-year-old farmer Pancham Singh. The cost of health care per family in Amatikra village has also increased in the last two decades, adding to their economic woes.

Chhattisgarh's fluorosis problem

A wider context to this problem is that 17 out of 27 districts, which include 592 villages, in Chhattisgarh show fluorosis as one of the major public health problems today. Unfortunately, there is no clear method to address this issue. One possible solution is the early detection of fluoride in the groundwater in other villages. These sources could be avoided and others found. Maybe the government could offer subsidies to the villagers that need treatment. At least, their healthcare bills would reduce. The villagers in Amatikra say that the government authorities have never taken any visible initiative to mitigate this problem in the area.

Ironic, given that they were the cause of the problem in the first place.

Disclaimer: This article, authored by Makarand Purohit, was first published in India Water Portal.