Meeting of the minds: Why policy should be on the dashboard of entrepreneurs
Which economic sectors are being most disrupted in India today? How can the interests of consumers and industry be balanced? Who are the experts in these domains, and how can they contact and collaborate with one another? What policies of today will need urgent overhaul tomorrow? What can be done to prepare for the ‘unknown unknowns’ of tomorrow?
The ever-escalating pace of disruptive innovation is making for unlikely policy bedfellows of startups, tech titans, academics, civil society and government. Events like the Global Technology Summit have shed light on dialogue formats and outcomes for such multi-stakeholder forums. The Summit was held in Bengaluru and saw several prominent personalities discussing the future of technology, particularly in the India context.
“Stakeholders in both Delhi and Bengaluru recognise that there needs to be a greater dialogue on technology and policy,” said Shivnath Thukral, Managing Director, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace India.
Innovators are pushing the policy boundary of regulation, observed Rahul Matthan, lawyer at TriLegal. He recalled how digital network access laws in India had to be changed to give MNCs like Texas Instruments operational foundations in Bengaluru way back in the 1980s. Much has changed since then, with policy implications affecting sectors ranging from e-commerce and cab sharing to digital security and industrial robotics. Here are my Top 15 takeaways from the event, in terms of implications for tech entrepreneurs and government.
Disruption can happen to countries and societies as well, not just companies, said Ravi Venkatesan, Chairman of Bank of Baroda. Job loss will be widespread – new jobs will be in the innovation frontiers of robotics, mostly in the US, China, Japan and Europe. India needs to understand, embrace and harness the fourth industrial revolution.
This may even call for simplification of visa rules to attract global talent to India. The notion of a job is changing – the current concepts of career, retirement and pension will become outdated. Life will become ‘a series of parallel gigs’.
Creating a ‘policy sandbox’
The Government and regulators should create a ‘policy sandbox’ to experiment with and test different policy frameworks such as smart cities and robotics. This pilot test approach can work better than a ‘big bang’ approach, reducing risks, uncovering hidden ecosystem relationships and working out policy impacts.
The challenge for policymakers is that such testing can involve mistakes and failures, and governments are loathe to accept errors and perceptions of wasting tax dollars. However, this approach will help policymakers listen to, understand and accommodate the concerns of many stakeholders.
AI – Regulation at the frontiers
Artificial Intelligence has been around for 50 years, but has suddenly shot to prominence, observed Prof. Shivaram Kalyanakrishnan, IIT Bombay. Drivers and markets for AI today are the internet, smartphones, IoT and data archives. Deep learning in teleradiology can help make up for medical skill shortages in India. Trends to watch are the intersection of AI and ‘crowd’ behaviour.
There needs to be a mix of optimism as well as caution in rolling out AI; open mindedness is needed for adopting new ways of doing things, said Shivaram. He called for more electronic record-keeping in India, strong research tracks in universities, and long-term investments by government, academia and industry.
“Think core tech, not just selling vegetables through apps. India can take a global lead in AI,” said Shivaram. Some of these technologies are at the new frontiers of regulation; many countries are drawing up legislation for adoption of drone usage. The use of robots and co-bots will also affect industrial employment laws, ethics and practices.
Industry and policy
Factories of the future will increasingly be driven by cyber-physical systems, said GNV Subba Rao, Head of India Centre for Global R&D at ABB. Trends to watch include AR (Augmented Reality), automatic testing, plug and play devices, data in supply chain, manufacturing and 3D printing.
Indian companies and units are stepping up to the challenge: smart sensors developed in India have helped reduce motor downtime by 70 percent, extend lifetime by 30 percent, and increase energy efficiency by 10 percent. This will change the way manufacturing is conducted, and the rise of robotics will lead to new kinds of laws and regulation.
Startups are great at prototypes, but industry and government must help scale them, advised Ravi Puvvala, Founder and CEO, Savari. The company’s Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) communication solutions can be used for making fleets smarter and even driverless.
Indian output in terms of publications and patents also needs to improve. Metrics of industry research output include patents, publications and collaborations, according to Deepanwita Chattopadhyay, Chairman and CEO of IKP Knowledge Park. These metrics can be further classified at multiple levels: nation, state and stakeholder.
Each industrial sector has different innovation thresholds and patent profiles, and needs separate patent policies, said GS Madhusudan, Principal Scientist at IIT Madras. ‘Instant patenting’ slowed the takeoff of 3D printers; it is not necessary to put patents first, cautioned Madhusudhan. See YourStory’s coverage on IP strategies for startups, and the common mistakes founders make.
Technology and jobs
Comparisons between the West and India need to be nuanced, since both have different problems and perceptions regarding wages and jobs. “India has to get rid of regulatory cholesterol,” said Manish Sabharwal, Founder, TeamLease.
If the country wants to promote ‘Make in India’ to the world, it needs to master frugal innovation and compete in global quality, advised Wilfried Aulbur, Managing Partner, Roland Berger. China is the largest buyer of robots globally, and has much higher use of robots in manufacturing than India. India needs to drive its industry into the 4.0 model as well. Germany, Korea and China have good industry-government-academic cooperation; such collaboration needs to be increased in India.
Inclusion and productivity
India is innovating in the area of affordable access to new products and services. The future is also about part-time jobs, not just full-time jobs, said Kiran Mazumdar Shaw, Managing Director, BioCon. The rise of Uber and Ola drivers in India is a good example of new job creation through technology and improved productivity in a short time, observed Sharad Sharma, Co-Founder of iSPIRT.
The key challenges for India are better education and dignity of labour, said T V Mohandas Pai, Co-founder of Aarin Capital. Indian regulators will need a good mix of generalists and specialists for tech policy to address emerging frontiers in this space.
New transportation technologies call for improved decision making and smart investments by government, said Bibop Gresta, Co-founder, Hyperloop Transportation Technologies. “We are faster than the Bullet Train and more efficient,” he said.
Hyperloop is not just a disruption in transportation, but innovation in the way it is being built. The company is exploring infrastructure investment in India in sectors like the Mumbai-Pune corridor.
“The greatest development comes from knowledge,” said MJ Akbar, Minister of State in the Ministry of External Affairs. This calls for cross-sectoral dialogue and cooperation between different pockets of expertise.
Delhi and Bengaluru need to work together on the technology policy front. “Bengaluru needs to understand Delhi,” joked Akbar. “Add Mumbai also to the mix – it has the RBI and major banks,” quipped Nandan Nilekani.
National and state level investments in incubators and accelerators will help evolve the right innovation mix for India. NE8Startups is Northeast India’s first startup accelerator, said Deepanwita of IKP Knowledge Park. See also YourStory’s Startup Hatch series of incubator and accelerator profiles in India.
Technology and diplomacy
Tech diplomacy, or the blending of technology with foreign policy, plays a key role in taking economic advances global, said Nagaraj Naidu, Joint Secretary, Ministry of External Affairs.
Tech diplomacy is more pressing now than ever before thanks to concerns like global warming and cyber-security. Technology makes managing diplomacy and government communication easier – and even changes how wars are fought.
Industry and state governments
“Bengaluru is one of the knowledge capitals of the world. Industry has helped the state formulate policy, starting in 1997,” explained RV Deshpande, Karnataka Minister for Large and Medium Industries. Karnataka created India’s first Startup Policy, and set up an investment fund in 2000; now, it is setting up a fund of funds.
“We do listen to the concerns of startups; we have met with Ola four times in the last month,” said Priyank Kharge, Minister of IT, Karnataka. The state has also organised the BangaloreITE.biz summit, New Age Incubation Network and Startup Cell to engage with startups.
“India’s central government should learn from Karnataka about startup policy, and the Karnataka government should learn marketing from the central government,” joked Priyank.
Smart city solutions: Access and standards
Smart initiatives like smart cities can be inclusive, and should not be regarded as elite, said RK Misra, Founder and Director of the Center for Smart Cities. Emerging feasible ‘smart’ scenarios for India need to be systematically examined. Smart city solutions call for more harmonisation of protocols. Converging technologies will create societal solutions, but major collaboration is needed.
An estimated $341 billion will be wasted by 2025 if IoT standards are not implemented, cautioned Sameer Sharma, GM, IoT Solutions, Intel. Emerging standards organisations include Industrial Internet Consortium, Open Fog, Open Connectivity Foundation, and IoTivity. For IoT to succeed, solutions will need to be secure, scalable and interoperable.
Smart buildings and homes require fixed broadband (wireless, landline), but cloud computing for smart homes in India won’t scale unless there is fixed broadband to the home, cautioned Craig Garen, VP, Global R&D, Intel.
Demonetisation and beyond
Demonetisation represents an important moment for India - the policy window has opened up for digital payments, said Nandan Nilekani, architect of Aadhar. Other examples of policy windows opening up in India include the onset of liberalisation in 1991.
Though the implementation of demonetisation has left a lot to be desired, the fact is that digitisation has been accelerated. The cash economy value chain is under government control; digital opens up new players and new business models based on data.
Aadhar has crosses a billion citizens, and 12-14 million authentications are carried out each day. This has spawned other innovations like eKYC, digital lockers and so on. eKYC has accelerated scale options for companies, said Nandan. Micro-ATMs and USSD (Unstructured Supplementary Service Data) can reach Indians who don’t have smartphones.
Policy is now increasing competitive intensity in Indian banking and payment sectors. The disruptive power of digital payments is in high volume, low cost and low fee transactions. Fee-based business model companies will collide with free transaction digital players, said Nandan. The decrease in operation costs will make it easier for financial companies to increase their reach and thereby bring about financial inclusion. Digital can reduce corruption as well as friction.
There have been IoT-coordinated botnet DDOS attacks on a scale never seen before, said Sameer Sharma, IoT Solutions, Intel, referring to the Mirai attacks. The rise of digitalisation and demonetisation in India has also opened the door to new risks of cyber-attacks, and the government needs to do more to increase digital literacy.
Digital players are stepping up to the challenge and improving payment features, information security and cybersecurity. Cybersecurity task forces are emerging at the state and national levels. See also the report ‘Future of the Internet in India’ by YourStory, NASSCOM and Akamai.
Foreign capital, foreign companies
Should there be a level playing field in India for foreign capital and global players, alongside the local ecosystem? Opinions and benchmarks differ; China and Korea have grown their local industries through protectionist measures. There have also been concerns about the confusion regarding Indian government legislation on FDI into e-commerce.
In comparison, India has not recognised the consumer internet economy as a strategic pillar the way China has, according to Bhavish Aggarwal, Founder, Ola Cabs. It is the management team that defines what is ‘national’, not the capital, he said.
High-end jobs of global players remain in the West, observed Sachin Bansal, Co-Founder of Flipkart. He said that India should think more about self-reliance, and industry should be included at the policy table. He called for better policies on data privacy in India.
Foreign companies do play an important role in innovation in India, with many entrepreneurs learning their early skills there, pointed out Navneet Kapoor, President, Target India. Areas of friction will be in government sovereignty of cloud hosting and data, said Anand Rangarajan, Engineering Director, Bangalore Site Lead at Google.
The road ahead
The Indian education system needs serious reform to encourage broad-based innovation. “The Indian education system kills innovative thinking right from the beginning. We have good research resources in India, but a poor innovation mindset,” said GS Madhusudan, Principal Scientist at IIT Madras.
Indian parents are also to blame – they ask children to focus on exams, and not on projects or hobbies. And students are also to blame – many engineering students end up working for financial companies, he said.
An estimated 497 million Indians will move from rural to urban India in the next 35 years – equivalent to 1.5 Americas, said Kamal Bali, Managing Director, Volvo. For development solutions to be sustainable, they have to be economically viable, socially inclusive, and environmentally friendly. “We must make sustainable solutions desirable,” said Kamal.
“The Global Technology Summit helped us identify issues that need serious policy thinking and work in the coming year. We plan to have a deep dive on issues planned every quarter, starting in March. The year will also see policy briefs, research papers and smaller convening sessions. This will culminate into the second edition of the Global Tech Summit in December 2017,” said Shivnath of Carnegie Endowment, in an interview after the Summit.
- Sharad Sharma
- Managing Director
- nandan nilekani
- sachin bansal
- Aarin Capital
- Target India
- Navneet Kapoor
- Mohandas Pai
- Smart city
- Ravi Venkatesan
- Kiran Mazumdar Shaw
- Manish Sabharwal
- IKP Knowledge Park
- Kamal Bali
- Bank of Baroda
- Priyank Kharge
- Bibop Gresta
- Deepanwita Chattopadhyay
- Shivnath Thukral
- Anand Rangarajan
- Craig Garen
- Nagaraj Naidu
- Wilfried Aulbur
- Sameer Sharma
- Center for Smart Cities
- Roland Berger
- Minister for Large and Medium Industries
- Rahul Matthan
- Carnegie Endowment
- Shivaram Kalyanakrishnan
- cyber-physical systems