Macquarie cuts target price on Paytm citing 'tough times ahead'; Paytm shares down 2.8pc
Research firm Macquarie slashed's stock target price by 36 percent to Rs 450 following the Reserve Bank of India's ban on Paytm Payments Bank from onboarding any new customers, due to alleged data leaks to Chinese firms.
Paytm has denied the Bloomberg report, which said Paytm was leaking data to its indirect Chinese shareholders, calling the source-based story "false" and "sensationalising".
However, that has not stoppered its stock losses this week. Paytm opened Monday at a record low, and its shares have continued to take a beating over the past few days. Worth noting though that broader markets have been trending low too, and some of Paytm's dips could have been exacerbated by that pressure.
Macquarie says the RBI directive significantly reduces the probability of Paytm getting a banking license to lend, and there could be tougher times ahead. It added that regulatory headwinds, from the central bank's regulations on digital payments, BNPL and stricter KYC and compliance norms could further cloud Paytm's path towards profitability.
"With the RBI recently raising issues with Paytm payments bank and Chinese ownership being 25 percent-plus, we believe the probability of Paytm getting a banking license is significantly lower now, thereby impeding its ability to lend," Macquarie analyst Suresh Ganapathy wrote in a note.
Paytm's stock performance since it listed in November 2021.
"Given this, and competition from other Fintechs in the payments space, we remain sceptical about Paytm's longer-term ability to generate free cash flow," he added.
Macquarie's previous target price on Paytm was Rs 700. It has maintained its underperform rating on the stock, as well as retained its earnings estimates.
Paytm's shares were down 2.68 percent at Rs 617.05 at the time of writing this report. It slipped to Rs 592.45 on Tuesday - its lowest ever, and at a 3.6X discount to its listing price of Rs 2,150.